Add Optional Settings below-tab lyric placement for tab-only and standard+tab layouts #2761
AvaTheArchitect
started this conversation in
Ideas
Replies: 0 comments
Sign up for free
to join this conversation on GitHub.
Already have an account?
Sign in to comment
Uh oh!
There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.
Uh oh!
There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.
-
Summary
This is a feature request for optional lyric placement in tab-focused layouts.
Currently, lyrics render above the tab staff. That may be expected current behavior, but in tab-only or standard+tab guitar layouts, lyrics can compete with bends, dive bombs, slides, vibrato, technique text, and other above-staff guitar effects.
The request is to add an option to render lyrics below the tab staff.
Problem
For guitar tracks, the area above the tab staff is often already occupied by guitar-specific notation:
When lyrics are also placed above the tab staff, the renderer may need a large amount of vertical space to avoid collisions. Even with improved skyline/effect positioning, above-staff lyrics can still be a poor fit because the upper lane is already crowded by guitar notation.
This is especially visible in tab-only layouts or standard+tab layouts where lyrics would often be more readable below the tab staff.
Requested behavior
Add an option to place lyrics below the tab staff in tab-focused layouts.
Possible API shape:
Expected behavior:
Reference behavior
Guitar Pro provides a lyrics placement option under text/style settings with choices such as:
The attached Guitar Pro screenshots show this setting directly.
This makes tab-focused guitar layouts more readable when the upper staff area is occupied by bends, dive bombs, and other guitar effects.
Image 1 — Problem example
In the attached Guns N’ Roses example, the lead guitar track includes lyrics plus upper-staff guitar effects. Because the lyrics are above the tab staff, they compete with bends/divebombs/effects and require significant vertical headroom.
Image 2 — Expected visual direction / proof of concept
The attached Maestro screenshot shows a custom below-staff lyric overlay rendered under the tab staff. This is not being proposed as the exact implementation for alphaTab, but it demonstrates the layout goal:
Image 3 — Guitar Pro setting
Guitar Pro stylesheet setting showing Lyrics set to Below Staff.
Image 4 — Guitar Pro available options
Guitar Pro dropdown showing Above Staff, Below Staff, and Hide.
Image 5 — Guitar Pro available options (expanded menu drawer)
Guitar Pro dropdown showing Above Staff, Below Staff, and Hide.
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
All reactions