Skip to content

qa-test-012.md

Latest commit

 

History

History
77 lines (52 loc) · 3.56 KB

qa-test-012.md

File metadata and controls

77 lines (52 loc) · 3.56 KB

QA Test Report — MoneyMirror issue-012 (Gen Z clarity loop)

Date: 2026-04-07
Run: 1
Model: Codex / GPT-5 (gpt-5)
Command: /qa-test
Issue: issue-012 — Gen Z clarity loop (emotional UX, frequency-first insights, perf SLAs)
Peer Review gate: APPROVED (experiments/results/peer-review-012.md)

Functional Tests

  • Automated suite: npm --prefix apps/money-mirror test -> 32/32 files, 159/159 tests, PASS
  • Focused issue-012 suite: npm --prefix apps/money-mirror run test -- __tests__/api/frequency-clusters.test.ts __tests__/api/guided-review-outcome.test.ts src/app/dashboard/__tests__/InsightsPanel.test.tsx src/components/__tests__/GuidedReviewSheet.test.tsx -> 4/4 files, 19/19 tests, PASS
  • GET /api/insights/frequency-clusters behavior verified via tests: debit-only aggregation, stable cluster rollups, and scope-safe totals -> PASS
  • POST /api/guided-review/outcome behavior verified: authenticated ownership checks and server-side privacy enforcement (dismissed=true persists commitment_text=NULL) -> PASS
  • Guided review UX completion path verified: non-2xx response keeps step visible with retry instead of false success -> PASS

Edge Cases

  • Empty/invalid payload guards remain enforced on issue-012 routes (400 / 401 paths covered by tests) -> PASS
  • Frequency insights with sparse data return safe empty shapes instead of runtime failures -> PASS
  • Guided review dismiss path works without commitment persistence (privacy-minimal path) -> PASS

Failure Scenarios

  • Telemetry unavailability contract rechecked for cron workers: PostHog calls are wrapped to avoid worker hard-fail on telemetry exceptions -> PASS
  • Worker failure-path telemetry expectation remains present from prior cycle contract (catch-path emission + aggregate failure accounting) -> PASS
  • Guided review API failure path now surfaces explicit retryable UI feedback and blocks false completion -> PASS

Performance Risks

  • No regression detected in issue-012 test run timings (focused suites complete quickly; no new long-tail test paths)
  • Residual non-blocking risk remains unchanged from earlier cycles: some AI timeout paths still rely on Promise.race semantics rather than transport-level abort for all providers
  • T0 SLA instrumentation (dashboard_ready_ms, time_to_first_advisory_ms) is present and tested in current scope; no blocking perf finding in QA

UX Issues

  • Skeleton-first and progressive disclosure paths are stable under automated tests -> PASS
  • Guided review completion now correctly handles unhappy-path API responses with retry affordance -> PASS
  • No new blocking UX reliability defects found for T0-T2 surfaces in issue-012

Env Var Cross-Check

Source key audit against .env.local.example passed (no missing keys observed in current process.env.* usage for apps/money-mirror/src + apps/money-mirror/scripts).

Verified keys include:

  • DATABASE_URL, NEON_AUTH_BASE_URL, NEON_AUTH_COOKIE_SECRET
  • GEMINI_API_KEY, RESEND_API_KEY
  • POSTHOG_KEY, POSTHOG_HOST
  • NEXT_PUBLIC_POSTHOG_KEY, NEXT_PUBLIC_POSTHOG_HOST
  • NEXT_PUBLIC_PAYWALL_PROMPT_ENABLED, NEXT_PUBLIC_APP_URL
  • CRON_SECRET, WHATSAPP_API_URL, WHATSAPP_API_TOKEN
  • runtime/test flags (NODE_ENV, NEXT_RUNTIME, VITEST)

Final QA Verdict

PASS

  • Full regression suite is green (159/159)
  • Issue-012 focused suites are green (19/19)
  • No blocking functional, reliability, or UX findings remain for issue-012
  • Pipeline can advance to /metric-plan